You ordered more cement tile than you needed. Or less. Or the color looked different on screen than it does sitting in your kitchen. Whatever the reason, you’re now asking the question every tile buyer eventually asks: can you return cement tile once it’s shipped? The honest answer is “sometimes, with conditions” — and those conditions depend on whether you bought in-stock or custom tile, whether the boxes are still sealed, and how fast you move.
We’ve spent over a century making cement tile by hand in San Luis Potosí, Mexico, and we’ve fielded this question more times than we can count. This guide walks through what’s typically returnable, what almost never is, and — just as important — what to do with the boxes you’re stuck with either way.
Why Cement Tile Returns Work Differently Than Other Flooring
Cement tile isn’t printed or mass-manufactured. Each tile is hand-poured, pressed, and cured in small batches, which is why the color and texture have a little life to them. That same handmade process is also why returns get complicated.
A box of machine-made ceramic tile is identical to the next box off the same line, year after year. Cement tile is not. Every production run is its own batch, sometimes called a “dye lot,” and later batches can shift slightly in shade because pigments are mixed by hand. So if a retailer takes a box back today and resells it to another customer in six months, there’s a real chance it won’t match that customer’s existing floor anymore.
That’s why most cement tile returns — ours included — hinge on two things: the box has to be unopened and unused, and the return has to happen quickly, while that batch is still active inventory. Once a tile has been cut, installed, or left in a garage for a year, a clean return usually isn’t realistic anymore.
Can You Return In-Stock Cement Tile?

In-stock patterns are the easier case. Because these designs are already sitting in our Laredo, TX warehouse and ship within days, unopened boxes from the in-stock tile collection are generally the most workable kind of return. The tile hasn’t been custom-mixed for your order, so it can realistically go back into inventory for someone else.
That said, don’t assume a return is free or automatic. Across the tile industry, returns almost always come with conditions worth knowing before you order:
- Full, sealed boxes only. Opened cartons, cut tiles, or partial boxes are rarely accepted because they can’t be resold as new.
- A time window applies. Most sellers give you a set number of days from delivery, not months. If you’re not sure how much extra tile you’ll need, decide fast.
- A restocking fee is common. It’s standard across the flooring industry to deduct a percentage to cover the cost of inspecting, repackaging, and re-shelving returned material.
- Freight usually isn’t refunded. You paid to get the tile to your door; getting it back typically falls on you, and the original shipping charge rarely comes back either way.
Because the exact window and fee can vary by order size and how the tile was shipped, the fastest way to get a straight answer is to reach out through our contact page before you ship anything back. We’d rather sort it out with you directly than have you guess.
Custom Cement Tile: Why It’s Usually Final Sale
Custom tile is a different story, and this is where most buyers get caught off guard. When you choose a pattern from our custom made tile collection, you’re not pulling from a shelf. You’re asking our factory to mix a specific pigment combination and press it into a mold, made to order over roughly four to six weeks, just for your project.
That tile doesn’t exist until you order it. There’s no warehouse shelf to put it back on if you change your mind, because nobody else wants your exact color combination sitting in their project. For that reason, custom orders are typically treated as final sale once production has started, with no return path for a simple change of heart.
This is also why we push hard on sampling before you commit to a custom run. A sample costs far less than a pallet of tile you can’t send back. If you’re on the fence about a custom color, order the sample, set it on the actual floor in daylight, and live with it for a day or two before the factory starts pouring.
Exchanges vs. Returns: When a Swap Makes More Sense
A return gets you money back. An exchange gets you the right tile instead. If your issue is “I ordered the wrong pattern” rather than “I don’t want tile anymore,” ask about an exchange first — it’s often a faster, cleaner fix than processing a refund.
Exchanges still come with the same ground rules as returns: boxes need to be sealed and unused, and the clock is ticking. If you’re swapping toward a different shade altogether, it’s worth a fresh look at the full collection before the old order goes back.
One thing an exchange won’t fix: installed tile. Once cement tile is set in mortar and grouted, it has been accepted as-is. That’s true whether the installer loved it or not, so this is the moment to stop and double-check the pattern, size, and quantity — not after the thin-set has cured.
The Smart Way to Avoid Needing a Return
The best return policy is never needing one. A little planning upfront saves you the restocking fee, the shipping hassle, and the wait entirely.
Start with a sample. First samples run $20 and additional ones are $10, with free shipping, from any in-stock product page. That’s a small price to confirm color, texture, and scale against your actual cabinets, grout, and light before you buy a full order.
Next, order the right quantity the first time. We recommend adding 15% over your measured square footage to cover cuts, breakage, and future repairs — an 8×8 box covers 5.17 square feet, or 12 tiles, so the math is easy to check against your room size. Our installation guidelines walk through layout and cutting in more detail, because the pattern you choose changes how much waste to expect.
Finally, measure twice before you order custom. Because custom tile can’t be returned once production starts, confirm your square footage, pattern, and border details with your installer first. A quick call to request a quote is a cheap way to catch a mistake before it’s poured in cement.
What to Do With Leftover Boxes After the Job

Even with careful ordering, extra boxes happen. Floors are never perfectly rectangular, and breakage during cutting is normal. Instead of fighting a return, here’s what to do with what’s left over.
- Keep one full box as a repair reserve. Because cement tile shifts slightly between batches, a chipped tile five years from now is much easier to replace if you already have a matching box on hand instead of hunting for a close color.
- Use extras for small accent projects. A handful of leftover tiles makes a great tray liner, a planter base, a step riser, or a backsplash insert behind a range hood.
- Store them properly. Keep boxes flat, off concrete floors, and away from moisture so the tiles don’t absorb dampness before you need them. Our maintenance and cleaning guide covers how cement tile handles moisture once it’s installed, and the same caution applies to tile still in the box.
- Pass them along. If you have more than a box or two left, a local renovation reuse store, a neighbor mid-remodel, or an online marketplace listing can turn dead inventory into cash or goodwill instead of clutter in your garage.
Whatever you do, resist tossing leftover boxes in the trash right after the job wraps. That extra box is cheap insurance against a mismatched repair later, and it costs nothing to store a few tiles flat in a closet.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I return cement tile after it’s been installed?
No. Installation is treated as acceptance of the product across the tile industry, cement tile included. Once tile is set and grouted, there’s no return path, which is why checking color and quantity before installation matters so much.
Do I have to pay a restocking fee to return cement tile?
Often, yes. A restocking fee is standard practice across tile sellers to cover inspection and repackaging costs on returned material. The exact fee and return window can vary by order, so confirm specifics before you ship anything back.
Can I return custom made cement tile if I change my mind?
Generally, no. Custom tile is mixed and pressed specifically for your order, so once production starts, there’s no inventory to put it back into. That’s why ordering a sample before committing to a custom color is worth the small cost.
What should I do if a box arrives damaged?
Damaged-in-transit tile is a different issue from a change-of-mind return, and it’s handled differently. Document the damage with photos right away and reach out through our contact page so we can get replacement tile moving instead of processing a standard return.
See the tile in person before you commit
Photos only tell you half the story. Colors, texture and the handmade character of cement tile are best judged in your own light. Order a sample of any in-stock pattern for $20 (additional samples $10, free shipping) — or tell us about your project and we’ll help you narrow it down.
Browse in-stock cement tiles →
Talk to us about your project →



